The Department of Transport says that while low surrender rates are a concern, the more important factor is that court disqualifications are enforced.
New figures reveal that learner drivers in Kildare who were disqualified in court are among the least likely in the country to hand in their permits.
According to Department of Transport data, 93 learner drivers in Kildare were disqualified in 2023, with just five surrendering their permits - a rate of 5.38%.
In 2024, the figure dropped to 75 disqualifications, with three permits surrendered.
So far in 2025, up to the end of August, there have been 64 disqualifications, with just four drivers handing in their permits, a surrender rate of 6.25%.
The Department of Transport says that while low surrender rates are a concern, the more important factor is that court disqualifications are enforced.
Drivers are legally barred from driving regardless of whether they hand in their permits.
An Garda Síochána can identify disqualified drivers through the National Vehicle and Driver File (NVDF), with the power to detect and prosecute those caught driving while banned.
The Department also shares information on non-surrendered licences with Gardaí, though it does not track follow-up penalties - a responsibility that falls under the Department of Justice.

Nationwide Fuel Protest Continues Into Third Day
"I Don't Think Anybody Is Going To Really Listen To Us Until Somebody Dies On That Road": Criticism Of Moone-Timolin Cycleway Continues
International Wholesale Prices Are "Not Price Gouging", Says CCPC
Costs Of Home Heating Oil Up By 67.5 Per Cent Between February and March
91-Year-Old Lelia Doolan To Arrive In Monasterevin Today As Part Of Her Walk For Peace
Over €400,000 Awarded To Repair And Protect Three Kildare Heritage Structures
€7,750 In Grants Awarded to Kildare Groups Promoting Activity Among Older People
Property Prices On The Rise In Kildare, Report Finds